Design speed sets magnet mass
The relationship that governs everything else on this page: a generator’s torque requirement is inversely proportional to its design speed. A rotor turning at 12 rpm must produce enormous torque for a given power, and torque requires a large magnetic airgap area — which means magnet mass.
| Architecture | Magnet intensity | Why it is chosen | What it costs |
|---|---|---|---|
| Direct drive PMSG | Highest | No gearbox to fail — the dominant failure mode in wind. Best for offshore, where access is expensive | Very high magnet mass and heavy rare earth exposure; large, heavy nacelle |
| Mid-speed PMSG | Moderate | A single gearbox stage cuts magnet mass sharply while keeping much of the reliability benefit | Retains a gearbox, with its maintenance |
| High-speed geared PMSG | Low | Compact, light generator; least magnet exposure of the PM options | Full multi-stage gearbox |
| Doubly-fed induction | Minimal | Mature, cheap, minimal rare earth content | Slip rings, converter limitations, gearbox |
A units distinction worth getting right
Published figures move between kilograms of finished magnet and kilograms of neodymium per megawatt, and they differ by roughly a factor of three — neodymium is around 30% of the alloy by weight. A source quoting 50–150 kg Nd/MW and one quoting 400–700 kg magnet/MW may be saying the same thing. When comparing forecasts or building a procurement model, check which quantity is being counted before you conclude that two sources disagree.
The operating duty
Wind is a twenty-to-thirty-year asset with an access cost that can exceed the value of the part being replaced. That reshapes the specification priorities.
Offshore corrosion is the specification most likely to be wrong
A nacelle is not a sealed enclosure. It breathes, it condenses, and offshore that condensate is salt-laden. A standard nickel-copper-nickel coating that is entirely adequate for an onshore machine is a poor choice for a twenty-five-year offshore life, and a corroding magnet does not merely lose field — it swells, cracks and disintegrates from the grain boundaries outward, taking its retention with it.
Specify the coating against the real environment: nickel with an epoxy topcoat as a minimum for marine service, and consider the encapsulation of the whole magnet assembly rather than relying on a per-magnet coating. Replacing a corroded rotor segment offshore costs orders of magnitude more than the coating upgrade would have.
The supply exposure that comes with the architecture
Choosing direct drive is choosing a rare earth supply position. At several hundred kilograms of magnet per megawatt across a multi-hundred-megawatt project, the exposure is material rather than incidental — and wind consumes a substantial share of global magnet production.
What that means practically
- Heavy rare earth content drives licensing exposure. Grades carrying dysprosium and terbium — the SH class and above — fall under Chinese export licensing, adding roughly nine weeks of regulatory review to the schedule and a control regime that can tighten without notice. Detail in tariffs and country of origin.
- Grade right-sizing has real leverage here because the volumes are large. If a load-line analysis at the true rotor temperature and fault condition shows H class suffices where SH was specified, the saving scales across every turbine in the programme.
- Grain boundary diffusion is the underused answer. It achieves high-temperature coercivity with substantially less dysprosium than bulk alloying, at equivalent performance. For a magnet-intensive machine this is the single most effective exposure reduction available today — see reduced-Dy options.
- Ferrite direct drive is a real research direction, using flux concentration to compensate for lower energy density. It trades a much larger, heavier generator for zero rare earth content. Whether that trade works is entirely a function of whether the nacelle and tower can carry the mass — offshore, usually not.
- Long project timelines suit blanket commitments. Wind programmes have unusually good demand visibility, which is exactly the condition under which a blanket order with scheduled releases and price protection outperforms spot buying. See inventory programs.
- Second-source qualification is worth the cost at this scale. A single-mill dependency on a multi-year programme is a concentrated risk, and the qualification cost amortises across the volume — the protocol is in the second-source playbook.
End of life is becoming a design input
The first large wave of PM wind installations is approaching decommissioning, and a decommissioned direct-drive generator contains several tonnes of recoverable NdFeB in a known location and a known composition — far better feedstock than mixed consumer scrap. Recycled-content magnet supply is small today, but wind is one of the few applications where the recovery economics are genuinely favourable, and recycled-content expectations are appearing in procurement requirements. Worth positioning for rather than reacting to.
Beyond wind
The same magnet questions appear across the wider renewable and grid-adjacent sector, usually at smaller scale but with the same drivers.
| Application | Magnet role | Governing constraint |
|---|---|---|
| Hydro and micro-hydro | PM generator rotors | Low speed, continuous duty, humidity and immersion risk |
| Tidal and marine | Direct-drive PM generators | The most severe corrosion case in the sector; access cost higher again than offshore wind |
| Solar tracker drives | PM motors and position feedback | Wide ambient range, decades outdoors, very low duty cycle |
| Flywheel storage | PM motor-generator and magnetic bearings | High speed — retention against centrifugal load dominates |
| Grid-scale cooling and pumps | PM motors, magnetic couplings | Efficiency and sealed operation — see magnetic couplings |
| Heat pumps | Compressor motors | High efficiency in a sealed, refrigerant-wetted environment |
What we supply
- Arc segments and flat blocks for generator rotors, in H, SH and UH classes, to specified pole arc and magnetization direction.
- Coating systems matched to the environment, including nickel with epoxy topcoat for marine and offshore service.
- Per-lot material and coating certification, with salt spray qualification data.
- Grade right-sizing review against your load-line and fault case, which on a magnet-intensive machine is frequently worth more than any price negotiation.
What to send us
- Generator architecture, rated power and design speed
- Rotor temperature at sustained rated output, and the worst-case fault demagnetizing field
- Environment — onshore, coastal, offshore, or marine immersion
- Design service life and the accessibility for replacement
- Segment geometry, pole arc and quantity per machine
- Programme volume and schedule, so supply structure can be built around it
